Affordable Homeowners Insurance in New York

Top Companies

Hippo

3.1
- Quick instant quotes
- Complimentary smart devices included with every policy
- Policies you can tailor to your needs
- Quick instant quotes
- Complimentary smart devices included with every policy
- Policies you can tailor to your needs
$920

/ year

Get a Quote
Homesite

3.9
- A wide range of homeowners endorsement choices can strengthen a policy
- Web-based customer portal enables policy management
- Several discounts available for homeowners insurance
- A wide range of homeowners endorsement choices can strengthen a policy
- Web-based customer portal enables policy management
- Several discounts available for homeowners insurance
$1772

/ year

Get a Quote
Mercury

3.6
- Replacement cost coverage for extended dwelling available
- Coverage for valuable items available
- Discounts available for protective devices and fire-resistant construction
- Replacement cost coverage for extended dwelling available
- Coverage for valuable items available
- Discounts available for protective devices and fire-resistant construction
$819

/ year

Get a Quote
National General

4.0
- Custom360 coverage plans could simplify the quoting process
- Offers more promoted discounts than certain rivals
- Wide range of coverage choices and endorsements
- Custom360 coverage plans could simplify the quoting process
- Offers more promoted discounts than certain rivals
- Wide range of coverage choices and endorsements
$1654

/ year

Get a Quote
NYCM

3.9
- Special savings for newly renovated or newly bought homes
- 24/7 claims support
- Optional add-ons for equipment and appliance breakdowns and utility line coverage
- Special savings for newly renovated or newly bought homes
- 24/7 claims support
- Optional add-ons for equipment and appliance breakdowns and utility line coverage
$671

/ year

Get a Quote
Plymouth Rock

4.0
- Predefined coverage bundles offered
- Umbrella, pet, and flood insurance options offered
- Get quotes online
- Predefined coverage bundles offered
- Umbrella, pet, and flood insurance options offered
- Get quotes online
$1852

/ year

Get a Quote
Safeco

3.9
- Six homeowner policy endorsements
- Labor and materials warranty through the Guaranteed Repair Network
- Substantial multi-policy discount
- Six homeowner policy endorsements
- Labor and materials warranty through the Guaranteed Repair Network
- Substantial multi-policy discount
$1600

/ year

Get a Quote
Stillwater

3.0
- Highly customizable coverage options to fit specific needs
- Solid financial stability with excellent claim service ratings
- Competitive discounts for bundling and protective devices
- Highly customizable coverage options to fit specific needs
- Solid financial stability with excellent claim service ratings
- Competitive discounts for bundling and protective devices
$1800

/ year

Get a Quote
Swyfft

3.0
- Technology-powered quoting with rapid outcomes
- Coverage offered in select high-risk states
- Underwriting firms hold strong financial strength ratings from AM Best and Demotech
- Technology-powered quoting with rapid outcomes
- Coverage offered in select high-risk states
- Underwriting firms hold strong financial strength ratings from AM Best and Demotech
$1275

/ year

Get a Quote
The Hanover

3.4
- Low NAIC Complaint Index for homeowners product, suggesting overall customer satisfaction
- AM Best financial strength rating of A (Excellent)
- Endorsements enable policy customization, particularly beneficial for owners of high-value homes
- Low NAIC Complaint Index for homeowners product, suggesting overall customer satisfaction
- AM Best financial strength rating of A (Excellent)
- Endorsements enable policy customization, particularly beneficial for owners of high-value homes
$2886

/ year

Get a Quote
Trustage

3.0
- Hurricane endorsement offered in select states
- Round-the-clock customer support for insurance inquiries
- Potential savings for credit union members
- Hurricane endorsement offered in select states
- Round-the-clock customer support for insurance inquiries
- Potential savings for credit union members
$1575

/ year

Get a Quote
UPC

3.9
- Provided homeowners insurance in certain high-risk states
- Policies distributed via regional independent agents
- Made a limited selection of optional coverages available
- Provided homeowners insurance in certain high-risk states
- Policies distributed via regional independent agents
- Made a limited selection of optional coverages available
$2700

/ year

Get a Quote

Previous 1 2 3 Next

Ultimate Home Resources

More Insurance Options

Renters Insurance
Home Warranty

Popular Companies

USAA
4.8
Amica
4.6
Chubb
4.6
Progressive
3.7
Farmers
3.6
Erie
4.3
Allstate
4.2
State Farm
3.5
American Family
4.0
Liberty Mutual
3.8

View All Companies